i've been out of it and have just had the
dear abby stillbirth photo controversy brought to my attention by
laura. i haven't written about the issue in a long time, and not much even then, but laura's
post has brought to the surface what i've been meaning to say for a while, which is:
yes, of course, almost everyone who hasn't lost a child is uncomfortable with pictures of stillborn children. i remember going to d
eadbabymama's house and about passing out with the shock of seeing a picture of her husband holding strummer, right there on the shelf in their front room. justin, who knew her better and had spent some time traveling with her and talking about baby-anxiety stuff, thought it was perfectly normal, but i was bothered about it for months.
about three months to the day, actually. because that's when we lost hans. we took dozens of pictures of him before we let him go, and those pictures of him became the most precious things i owned. we looked at those pictures a dozen times a day, printed them out and framed some, put them in a small album which we included on a table at hans's memorial service along with the spanish books justin had gotten for him for christmas and the calendar we had gotten for him in belgium and the little alpaca sweater and hat our friend mike had brought him from peru and other things. we wondered how the pictures would be received, but we decided they were important to us, and we wanted them there for people who loved him to see. if anyone didn't want to see them, they didn't have to look at them; they were in a flip-album with a cover.
i often wanted to put hans's picture on my desk at work, but i never figured out how to do it in a way that would let me cherish him and show him to people who genuinely wanted to see him without exposing him to people who would disrespect him with their lack of understanding, so i never did it. that the mother in the letter that started this whole conversation was brave enough to do what i never had the ovaries to do blows me away. she deserves the purple heart or whatever the medal is they give for bravery. i hope she knows it.
so here's the thing: while i understand that most people are uncomfortable with pictures of stillborn babies, it doesn't make it okay. discomfort is not indicative of righteousness.
for much of our nation's history, a large percentage of people who identified as white were supremely uncomfortable at the thought of equality for blacks, much less frequenting the same businesses or sitting in the same section of the train or bus or - god forbid - their children socializing with black children. was that prejudice, that phobia, okay? no.
my late father was a minister, and while he did much to support and encourage younger ministers, he was extremely disparaging of women who attempted to enter the clergy. he was uncomfortable with women penetrating the ranks of pastors. it was okay for them to be children's pastors, or to direct a church-run preschool, or to maybe direct the missionary society, but not to be the senior pastor or - gasp - to preach. he saved special venom for a woman who rose to the top rank in his denomination, one of a board of six people who govern the denomination; he went out of his way to badmouth her at church conventions, to campaign against her eventual election. [at his funeral, the condolence letter that came from that board and was read out loud was signed by none other than that woman he hated. i had to smile.] was his treatment of her, and his opinion of women invading his profession okay? is the institutionalized discomfort with the equality of women in most of the world's religions okay? no, of course not.
i'm not equating my first son's worth with abolitionism or the equal rights amendment. but there are plenty of ways in which people are uncomfortable because of ignorance, and only after ignorance is dispelled does society in general learn to deal with the former bogeyman. it will take people like deadbabymama displaying strummer's picture alongside owen's. it will take me not giving into the pressure to say "yes" every time a restaurant server smiles at milo and asks me, "is he your first?" it will take the people who put those big pink and blue magnetic ribbons for infant loss on the backs of their cars to keep doing it until there are so many of those that every driver knows what they mean, as well-understood a symbol as yellow or red ribbons. it will take the international stillbirth society and other groups like it getting the kind of marketing savvy that the SIDS campaign has. it will take people like the woman in the letter to have the beans to display their child's picture on their desk.
p.s. strummer, i owe you an apology. the next time i see your picture, i'll be sure to give you your due.
Labels: rants, stillbirth